← Back to Concept Index

moral-dilemma

Father Ruiz-Sanchez grapples with the implications of his verdict on the Lithians, reflecting on the moral complexities of his role as a Jesuit in a foreign culture.

5 chapters across 4 books

A Case of Conscience (1958)James Blish

Chapter 13

In this chapter, the commission's decision regarding Lithia is revealed to be inconclusive, leading to further scrutiny from Earth. Father Ruiz-Sanchez receives a beautiful vase from Chtexa, which contains a fertilized egg of the Lithian species, symbolizing a complex relationship between the two worlds and the weight of his moral and ethical decisions.

Children of Time (2015)Adrian Tchaikovsky

Chapter 42

In this chapter, Fabian leads an army to Great Nest under the command of Viola, navigating the complexities of warfare and the moral implications of their actions. As negotiations unfold, the internal strife within Great Nest leads to a shift in power, allowing for a potential resolution to the conflict, but leaving Fabian to grapple with the consequences of his scientific discoveries and their use in warfare.

The Wanderer (1965)Fritz Leiber

Chapter 32

In this chapter, the protagonists arrive at a massive traffic jam on inland Route 101, witnessing a chaotic and violent standoff between teenagers and police amidst a backdrop of societal collapse and environmental distress. Doc reveals the conflict as a symbolic 'Day of the Children' war, emphasizing the futility of intervention given their limited resources, while Margo insists on investigating the nearby Vandenberg Three facility despite the risks. The chapter highlights the tension between self-preservation and the urge to aid others in a world unraveling.

Way Station (1963)Clifford D. Simak

Chapter 24

In this chapter, Enoch contemplates the catastrophic consequences of a sudden loss of knowledge and infrastructure, envisioning a collapse of civilization without war but through societal and technological decay. He wrestles with the moral dilemma of deciding whether to intervene in humanity's fate, questioning the right of one individual to make such a monumental choice. The chapter ends with Enoch feeling isolated and powerless, caught between loyalty to Earth and the wider galaxy.

Chapter 33

Enoch confronts a ratlike alien that has illegally traveled to Earth, a planet barred to extraterrestrials. He pursues the creature through a forested slope, grappling with the moral dilemma of capturing without killing it, while also contending with the alien's aggressive defense and the unexpected involvement of Lucy Fisher. The chapter culminates in a tense standoff atop a rocky outcrop where Enoch must decide whether to shoot the alien despite the darkness and proximity.